Snide Simon Cowell No Idol Of Blogs
Many Bloggers Say "American Idol" Snarkmeister Is Too Mean, Albeit Amusing



Moistworks
Gawker
Defamer
Lost Remote
Daily Kos
New Republic's The Plank
National Review's The Corner
Powerline
Footnoted


Photo Essay
Sixth Time For 'Idol'
'American Idol' returns with Simon, Paula and Randy to find yet another singing sensation.


Photo Essay
Road To American Idol
Meet the 12 'American Idol' finalists and find out how they've fared on the show.


RELATED STORIES & LINKS

"Idol" Auditions: A Parade Of Oddities
The Show Presents A Moral Dilemma: Are We Laughing At Or With The Contestants?


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rosie's New Target: Paula Abdul
O'Donnell Says "American Idol" Judge Was "Probably Intoxicated" On Reality Show


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Spanking Ban Debated
Calif. Lawmaker Floating Bill To Make Corporal Punishment A Misdemeanor


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bush Hosts School Safety Summit
President Urges Aggressive Action To Keep Kids Safe After Recent Shootings

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



NEW YORK, Jan. 24, 2007
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Simon Cowell, "American Idol" judge. (AP)








Got a good story? E-mail Melissa McNamara at Blogophile.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


(CBS) Blogophile is written by CBSNews.com's Melissa P. McNamara


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What Rhymes With Scowl?

Appearing on "American Idol" has never been for the faint of heart. After all, the show gained acclaim, in part, because audiences tuned in to hear Simon Cowell's harsh comments about contestants.

But have the judges crossed the line this year? Some claim that the judges' attacks on this year's contestants have become too personal, and downright mean.

The tryout of Jonathon Jayne, a Special Olympics athlete, drew heated criticism on TV after Cowell criticized his appearance, in addition to his performance. Cowell said another contestant looked like a creature from the jungle — a "bush baby."

For its part, Special Olympics International told the Washington Post that "American Idol" should be commended for giving one of their former athletes the opportunity to be seen on national TV.

But the blogosphere wasn't as understanding. But many bloggers question why contestants want to go before the judges — never mind the cameras — if they clearly lack real talent.